School Issued Devices Should Not Rely on Filtering Alone
Recent press coverage has highlighted a number of deeply concerning cases in which children have encountered harmful content through school-issued devices. The examples described range from grooming and self-harm content to radicalisation and exposure to pornography. As these stories understandably generate debate about the safety of technology in education, and the families who have been affected deserve to be heard, it is important to highlight what schools can do beyond their basic filtering requirements to keep their communities safe online.
Looking Beyond Filtering
The reality is that no single tool or system can protect children online in every circumstance. Effective safeguarding relies on a combination of technology, policy, people and education working together. When incidents occur, public discussion often focuses on the failure of filtering systems alone. Filtering is undoubtedly a critical component of online safety, helping schools prevent access to illegal and harmful content. However, filtering on its own cannot mitigate all forms of risk.
Many of the harms referenced in the coverage, including grooming, harmful communications, emerging AI risks and concerning behavioural changes, require a much broader safeguarding response. Effective filtering is an essential part of a school’s online safety provision, but it must be supported bymonitoring systems that can identify safeguarding concerns as well as securely configured devices that limit opportunities for misuse. Just as importantly, schools need clear safeguarding policies, staff who are trained and confident in responding to concerns, and age-appropriate education that helps children and young people recognise and navigate online risks for themselves.
Expectations and Responsibilities
We should also recognise how much responsibility now rests on schools. In England, schools have had a statutory duty since 2016 to provide appropriate filtering and monitoring, while the position differs in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. As technology becomes more complex, and privacy changes make content harder to see, filtering is becoming harder to apply well. Schools need more help and support, not just more expectations.
Responsibility for children’s online safety cannot rest with schools alone. Technology providers also have a crucial role to play in ensuring that the products and services they supply to education settings are designed with children’s safety in mind. School owned and managed devices can be protected far more effectively than devices that are not managed at all. School-issued devices, when properly configured and managed, provide an opportunity to put safeguards in place that may not be available when children use their own devices. Removing devices from schools is unlikely to address the wider challenges children face online. Instead, the focus should be on ensuring that technology is introduced and managed responsibly, with appropriate protections, education and staff training.
Strong communication with parents and carers also plays a vital role in ensuring that safeguarding remains consistent between school and home. When these elements work together, schools are far better placed not only to prevent harm where possible, but also to identify concerns early and respond effectively when issues arise.
A Whole-School Approach
The UK Safer Internet Centre has long advocated for a whole-school approach to safeguarding. Technology can be an incredibly powerful tool for education and digital development, yet technology should never be viewed as a safeguarding solution in isolation.Children need the knowledge and confidence to navigate online spaces safely. Staff need training to recognise signs of harm and understand how technology is being used across their organisation. Safeguarding leads need clear processes for managing incidents, and technical teams need confidence that systems are configured appropriately.
Online safety is most effective when it becomes part of the wider safeguarding culture of a school rather than being treated as a standalone technical issue.
Greater Assurance for Schools
One of the challenges facing schools is understanding whether the products and systems they invest in are delivering the level of protection they expect.
The UK Safer Internet Centre’s Filtering Accreditation scheme, which SWGfL runs as part of UKSIC, was created to provide greater transparency and assurance around filtering systems used within education settings. By assessing providers against established standards, accreditation helps schools better understand how these systems perform and how certain safeguarding expectations can be met in practice. It is not a guarantee. No system is fully effective, and accreditation covers filtering rather than monitoring, so schools still need to test and review what they use.
Alongside this work, tools such as TestFiltering Plus enable schools to consistently test filtering effectiveness against recognised standards and benchmark their provision. This helps move conversations away from assumptions and towards a more evidence-led assessment of how systems are performing.
Proposed Certification Scheme from DfE
The Department for Education’s current consultation in England on an EdTech and AI Product Safety Certification Scheme presents an important opportunity to strengthen assurance across educational technology. As schools increasingly rely on connected devices, cloud services and AI-powered tools, there is growing recognition that safety should be built into products and services from the outset, rather than considered after implementation. A certification approach has the potential to provide schools with clearer information about the safety features and standards built into the technologies they deploy.
As we have an interest in how certification develops, we would simply encourage everyone with an interest in education technology, safeguarding and online safety to read the consultation, which closes on 4 February 2027, and help shape future expectations for the sector.